Can VURB Replace NatHERS?

SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

Can VURB replace NatHERS?

The VURB vs NatHERS question comes up constantly for homeowners and builders trying to work out which energy assessment their project actually needs. Both are ways of demonstrating that a residential design meets NCC 2022 energy efficiency requirements, but they work very differently, and the honest answer to that question is: sometimes, but not always, and not in the way most people assume. This guide breaks down the comparison properly, so you know which pathway actually fits your project.

What Is a VURB Assessment?

VURB — Verification Using a Reference Building — is a Verification Method under NCC 2022 that assesses a design’s energy performance by modelling it against an equivalent reference building, rather than producing a star rating. VURB doesn’t check individual elements against fixed rules; instead, it compares the whole design’s energy modelling outcome to a reference building built to standard requirements, and the design either meets that benchmark or it doesn’t.

What Is a NatHERS Rating?

A NatHERS rating is the standard star-based assessment most people are familiar with, scoring a home’s thermal performance from 0 to 10 stars using accredited software. This rating tool assesses fixed building envelope elements — glazing, insulation, orientation — against benchmark assumptions built into the software, and most states require a minimum 7-star NatHERS rating for new homes under NCC 2022 (NSW achieves an equivalent outcome through BASIX rather than a direct star rating).

What’s the Difference Between the Two?

The core distinction between the two pathways comes down to how each one assesses a design. The standard star rating approach checks a home against fixed thermal performance assumptions using accredited software, producing a rating that’s easy to compare across projects. This pathway instead compares the whole design against a custom-modelled reference building, without producing a star rating at all — it’s a pass or fail outcome based on energy modelling rather than a scored result. The standard rating tool suits straightforward, conventional designs well; it suits designs that don’t fit the software’s built-in assumptions.

Can VURB Be Used Instead?

Yes, in specific circumstances — this pathway can be used instead of the standard rating software route when a design has features that make it difficult or unreliable to achieve, such as raked ceilings, unusual orientation, or extensive glazing. VURB is a Verification Method under H6V2 for Class 1 homes (and J1V5 for Class 2 apartments, though not in NSW), specifically intended as an alternative to the standard software route for designs where a typical star rating doesn’t work well — in effect, a residential Performance Solution built around a reference building rather than a fixed scoring system. It isn’t a universal substitute, though — for a conventional home design, the standard rating pathway remains the simpler, faster, and generally cheaper option, without needing a Performance Solution at all.

Is VURB Used for Residential Buildings?

Yes. VURB applies specifically to residential buildings — Class 1 houses and Class 2 apartments — the same building types the standard star rating tool is used for. Neither pathway applies to commercial buildings (Class 3, and 5 to 9), which instead use Section J and its own J1V3 Verification Method. If a project is genuinely commercial, this comparison doesn’t apply at all.

Which Pathway Is Better?

Neither is universally better — the right choice depends entirely on the design. For a conventional home with standard orientation and typical glazing, the standard rating tool is faster, cheaper, and easier to interpret through its familiar star system. For a home with genuine design constraints that a typical star rating struggles to accommodate, VURB is usually the more practical route, even though it typically costs more in modelling time. Choosing between the two pathways should be based on what actually suits the design, not a general preference for one over the other.

Can Mixed-Use Developments Require Both Approaches?

Not exactly both together on the same dwelling, but a larger development can involve a mix of approaches. A townhouse development might use the standard rating tool for the straightforward, conventional units and this pathway for a handful of units with unusual designs, sloping site constraints, or shared-wall complications that don’t suit standard software. Each dwelling is assessed on its own merits, so it’s entirely normal for one project to use both pathways across different units.

How Do I Know Which Assessment My Project Needs?

Start with the standard rating pathway as the default, and only consider VURB if the design runs into genuine difficulty — a failed rating despite reasonable specifications, or features like raked ceilings, curved walls, or heavy glazing that standard software wasn’t built to model well. An experienced assessor can usually tell early in design which pathway suits a project, which avoids wasted time attempting the wrong route first.

Is VURB the Same as a Performance Solution?

VURB is one specific type of Performance Solution available for residential buildings. Where the standard star rating approach is essentially a Deemed-to-Satisfy-style tool, this pathway sits within the Performance Solution category, alongside other verification approaches, all built around demonstrating an equivalent outcome rather than following a fixed rating process. A Performance Solution can also take other forms beyond this one, depending on what a design actually needs.

Final Thoughts

This question doesn’t have a single universal answer — the standard rating pathway remains the right default for most conventional homes, while VURB earns its place for the designs that pathway genuinely struggles with. Understanding the difference early, before a design is locked in, saves both time and money compared to discovering a standard rating won’t work after the fact. Torple’s VURB and residential energy assessment service can advise which pathway suits a specific design before committing to either, and can prepare the Performance Solution modelling this route requires, or the NatHERS rating documentation if that’s the better fit. For the official rating scheme, see nathers.gov.au.

FAQs

1. Can VURB replace NatHERS?

Sometimes. VURB can be used instead of a NatHERS rating when a design has features — like raked ceilings or unusual orientation — that make the standard rating difficult to achieve, but for conventional designs, the star rating tool remains the simpler option.

2. What is the difference between VURB and NatHERS?

The standard rating tool produces a star rating based on fixed thermal performance assumptions, while this pathway compares a design’s whole energy modelling outcome against a custom reference building, without producing a star rating.

3. Is VURB used for residential buildings?

Yes. Both pathways apply to residential buildings — Class 1 homes and Class 2 apartments — not commercial buildings, which use Section J instead.

4. Which is better: VURB or NatHERS?

Neither is universally better. The standard rating tool suits conventional designs; VURB suits designs with constraints that a typical rating struggles to accommodate. The right choice depends on the specific project.

5. Can mixed-use developments require both VURB and NatHERS?

A single development can use both approaches, assessed dwelling by dwelling — conventional units under the standard rating tool, and more complex or constrained units under VURB.

6. How do I know which assessment my project needs?

Start with the standard rating pathway as the default and consider VURB only if the design runs into genuine difficulty. An experienced assessor can usually tell early which one suits a project.

What do you think?
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

Insights

More Related Articles

Do Performance Solutions Increase Approval Complexity?

VURB for Complex Residential Developments

VURB for Dual Occupancies and Townhouses